Bio-based filler dosage from sunflower husk carbonizate

Bio-based filler dosage is the lever that decides whether an agricultural carbonizate behaves like a reinforcement or like a cost-cutting diluent. At 15 phr, sunflower husk carbonizates raised Mooney viscosity by up to 29.8 percent and pushed the torque difference to 27.1 dN m against 23.9 dN m for N772 carbon black, while the ash variant cut scorch time by up to 61.1 percent.

Why bio-based fillers are being pushed into rubber

Carbon black has been the default reinforcing filler for a century, because particle size, structure, and surface reactivity all line up well. It also comes from non-renewable feedstocks and is made at high temperature, with the polycyclic hydrocarbon and carbon dioxide load that goes with it. That combination is why formulators keep looking at agricultural residue.

Biochar from plant waste is the obvious candidate. Cellulose, lignin, chitosan, soy protein, coconut shell, rice husk, coffee grounds, and straw have all been tried, mostly with encouraging results. Rubber reinforcement is a hard place to make the substitution work, though, because the filler has to do three jobs at once: stiffen the compound, keep the mixing and shaping window workable, and hold its properties through thermo-oxidative aging.

Sunflower husk is an appealing feedstock because it is abundant and largely burned or dumped. It also carries lignin, hemicellulose, phenolic compounds, fatty acids, and a meaningful load of metal impurities. That last part cuts both ways. Metals can act as secondary activators in a sulfur cure, and they can also catalyze oxidative degradation later. Everything comes down to dosage.

How the sunflower husk carbonizates were made and tested

Husks were carbonized in a rotating tubular furnace under argon flowing at 1 liter per minute, held at temperature for 50 minutes. A separate material was produced in an oxidizing atmosphere at 650 degrees Celsius for 45 minutes, which burns out the carbon skeleton and leaves an ash.

Material codeAtmosphereTemperature (degrees Celsius)Hold time (minutes)
SHC300Argon30050
SHC400Argon40050
SHC500Argon50050
SHC600Argon60050
SHC700Argon70050
SHC800Argon80050
SHA650Oxidizing65045

The rubber was a special-purpose butadiene-nitrile grade with 17 to 20 percent acrylonitrile, picked for low impurity content and high plasticity so the filler effect would not get buried under other variability. Formulations were kept deliberately simple, and each carbonizate was tested at 5.0, 10.0, and 15.0 phr. The control set used N772 carbon black at the same loadings, so every comparison has a like-for-like reference.

IngredientParts by mass per 100 parts of rubber
Butadiene-nitrile rubber100.0
Stearic acid1.0
Zinc oxide3.0
Ground sulfur1.5
Sulfenamide C0.70

Mixing ran 21 minutes on a two-roll mill at 25 rpm and 45 degrees Celsius, with the filler added in two portions. Compounds rested 24 hours before vulcanization at 160 degrees Celsius, and vulcanizates rested another 24 hours before mechanical testing.

Surface area and pH move together with carbonization temperature

The reason processing temperature matters so much shows up in the surface data.

MaterialSpecific surface area (square meters per gram)Sorption volume (cubic centimeters per gram)pH of the aqueous suspension
SHC300130.0047.3
SHC400240.0067.9
SHC500320.0158.6
SHC600610.0269.1
SHC700940.0359.6
SHC8001030.04010.2
SHA650410.02511.1

Two trends run in lockstep. Surface area climbs from 13 to 103 square meters per gram as temperature rises, because pores only open once the plant components finish decomposing and the material becomes progressively more carbonized and more porous. At the same time pH rises from 7.3 to 10.2, as acidic functional groups disappear and alkaline and carbonate mineral phases concentrate.

The ash is the outlier, and a useful one. Burning out the carbon skeleton at 650 degrees Celsius leaves a loose residue with a moderate 41 square meters per gram but the highest pH of the whole set at 11.1, because the mineral fraction is enriched in potassium and calcium carbonates. Read the two columns together and most of what happens later in the rubber is already explained.

How bio-based filler dosage shifts processing behavior

Mooney viscosity is the first place a filler announces itself, and the response is monotonic.

Dosage (phr)Increase in Mooney viscosity (percent)Notes
5.0up to 11.1Compounds remain easy to process
10.0up to 19.6Processing energy rises noticeably
15.0up to 29.8Highest rises come from inert-medium carbonizates made at 400 to 800 degrees Celsius

The mechanism is not mysterious. Thermally treated plant particles are rigid and porous. They restrict segmental mobility, cut shear deformation, and make it harder for macromolecules to slide past one another, so the compound stiffens before it is cured. The biggest viscosity increases came from the inert-medium carbonizates with the highest carbon content, which is also the group with the largest surface area.

For a mixing room that table is a cost warning rather than a curiosity. Every step up in loading buys reinforcement with processing energy, and the relationship is roughly linear across the range tested.

Vulcanization kinetics: one surface accelerates and another slows

The oscillating disc rheometer results split the materials into two clearly different behaviors, and the split follows surface chemistry rather than carbon content.

Adding ash from the oxidizing route produced a sharp fall in scorch time, the point at which a compound starts to cure prematurely. The drop reached 61.1 percent against the unfilled compound and 54.3 percent against the carbon black reference. The explanation offered is the strongly alkaline surface at pH 11.1, which accelerates the sulfur reaction. A very short scorch time is a serious practical problem, because a compound that starts curing on the mill or in the die is scrap.

The inert-medium carbonizates behave differently. Scorch time drops only slightly, and the drop grows with both carbonization temperature and dosage. Metal oxides in the filler, magnesium oxide in particular, can act as secondary activators, forming complexes with the accelerator that are more reactive than the free accelerator and speeding the early stage of the cure.

Then comes the counterintuitive part. A filler that accelerates the early stage ought to shorten the time to reach the cure optimum, and that is what earlier work expects. Here the opposite happened: time to optimum cure went up. The explanation is morphological. Carbonizates made at higher temperature have large surface areas, and that surface adsorbs vulcanizing system components, which limits their availability and slows the later part of the reaction. High surface area is therefore a reinforcement asset and a cure kinetics liability at the same time.

Crosslink density rises with loading

The network data back up the torque measurements. Crosslink density, determined by equilibrium toluene swelling and reduced through the Flory-Rehner treatment, rose with loading across the board.

IndicatorUnfilled compoundN772 carbon black at 15 phrSHC700 at 15 phrSHC800 at 15 phr
Increase in maximum torque against the carbon black compoundlowest of the setreference11.1 percent10.0 percent
Difference between maximum and minimum torque (dN m)not reported23.927.126.7
Crosslink densitylowest of the setreferencehighest of the sethigh
Scorch timereferencereferenceslight decreaseslight decrease

The highest maximum torque and the largest torque difference both came from the 700 and 800 degree carbonizates at the top loading. The paper credits the extra crosslinking to the reactive metal impurities concentrated in these materials, which can take part in additional crosslinking reactions beyond the sulfur system.

There is a second network effect that only shows up after aging. Samples filled with the high-temperature carbonizates developed secondary crosslinking after thermal exposure, most likely because the high surface area adsorbed part of the curing package during vulcanization and left unreacted material available to crosslink later.

Mechanical properties: where the carbonizates match carbon black

Strength and elongation tell a more nuanced story than the network data.

The ash material is a clear failure as a reinforcing filler. At every dosage tested it reduced conditional tensile strength by 21.7 to 43.2 percent and cut relative elongation at break by a factor of 1.6 to 1.9 against the carbon black compound. That fits a loose, low-carbon residue that cannot carry load.

The inert-medium carbonizates are a different proposition. Strength rose with dosage against the unfilled compound, and the 600, 700, and 800 degree materials at 5, 10, and 15 parts landed within 0.3 MPa of the N772 carbon black compound at the same loadings. The best values came at the highest loadings, where filler-to-polymer contact area is greatest. Elongation at break fell by up to a factor of 1.3 against the reference, with the maximum elongation values again coming from SHC700 and SHC800 at 15 parts.

Composite strength is only half the picture. Ductility behaves differently from strength, and the carbonizates cost more of it than the network data alone would suggest.

The low-temperature carbonizates explain their own weakness. Below about 500 degrees Celsius the destruction of cellulose and lignin is incomplete, so residual plant material can keep decomposing and release organic gases during high-temperature vulcanization. Those gases leave voids in the cured article, and voids are crack initiation sites.

Fracture surfaces make the difference between a synthetic filler and a carbonized plant filler visible. The carbon black compound shows no large aggregates, because N772 particles are finely divided with high surface area and disperse into a continuous mesh. The carbonizate compounds look rougher and less uniform. Individual particles of the carbon framework are visible, ranging from irregular fragments to more defined shapes. The 300 to 500 degree samples carry voids left by escaping volatiles. The higher-temperature materials are highly porous, and that porosity appears to help them interact with the polymer matrix, which is consistent with strength values that match carbon black despite a much coarser structure.

Thermal aging: strength holds while elongation pays

Samples were held in air at 120 degrees Celsius for 72 hours to simulate service exposure, and the results split into a reassuring part and a cautionary one.

Property after 72 hours at 120 degrees CelsiusChange relative to the unaged value
Conditional tensile strength, carbon black and carbonizate filledwithin plus or minus 8 percent
Elongation at break, SHC700 at 15 phrminus 42.1 percent
Elongation at break, SHC800 at 15 phrminus 48.7 percent
Shore A hardness, carbonizates above 500 degrees Celsius at 15 phrwithin 3 Shore units, upward

Tensile strength is essentially preserved across the test, which is a genuinely good result for a bio-based filler and suggests the filler-carbon network is not degrading. Elasticity pays the price. The 700 and 800 degree carbonizates lost more than 40 percent of their elongation at break, and the paper ties that to the very same metal impurities that helped the cure. Those metals are strong oxidants once the temperature is high enough, and they intensify thermo-oxidative aging at the polymer-filler interface.

Hardness drifted upward slightly with loading for materials processed above 500 degrees Celsius, which fits the higher crosslink density and the larger solid carbon fraction. The change stayed inside 3 Shore units, so it is unlikely to move a product specification on its own.

Where the carbonizate route still trails carbon black

Three gaps stand out, and none of them is hidden by the headline numbers.

Processing cost is higher. A Mooney viscosity increase of up to 29.8 percent at 15 phr means more energy per kilogram of compound, and the rise is not offset by any reduction in cure temperature.

Scorch safety is worse, especially with the ash. Cutting scorch time by more than half leaves very little margin on a production line, and metal impurities can shift it further from batch to batch.

Elongation and aging behavior are the softest points. A 42 to 49 percent loss of elongation at break after aging is a real durability question for any dynamic application, even when tensile strength holds.

Taken together, the data support bio-based filler dosage up to 15 phr in this matrix, with 10 phr the safer entry point for a first trial.

Practical guidance on bio-based filler dosage

  • Treat the carbonization temperature as a formulation variable, not a feedstock detail. Going from 500 to 700 degrees Celsius roughly tripled surface area and moved pH by a full point.
  • Screen for the inert medium. The ash route gave a pH of 11.1 and the worst mechanical results in the study, with strength losses of 21.7 to 43.2 percent.
  • Expect a processing penalty that scales with loading. Mooney viscosity rose by up to 11.1 percent at 5 phr, 19.6 percent at 10 phr, and 29.8 percent at 15 phr.
  • Measure scorch time before anything else. It fell by up to 61.1 percent, and that is the number most likely to stop a trial on the factory floor.
  • Do not assume a faster early cure means a faster overall cure. Large surface area adsorbs the curing package and pushed the time to optimum cure up.
  • Test elongation after aging rather than strength alone. Strength stayed within 8 percent while elongation dropped as much as 48.7 percent.
  • Watch the metal content. The same impurities lift crosslink density by 10 to 11 percent against carbon black and accelerate oxidative aging at the same time.

Limitations

Only one rubber grade was used, a special-purpose butadiene-nitrile compound with 17 to 20 percent acrylonitrile, so the balance between reinforcement and cure interference may shift in a different polarity matrix. Carbon black was tested only as N772, a low-reinforcing grade, so the comparison does not establish behavior against a high-reinforcing grade such as N330. Several kinetic results are reported as percentage changes in figures rather than as absolute torque values, so the underlying scatter cannot be judged. Aging was limited to 72 hours at 120 degrees Celsius in air, which is a short-term screen rather than a service life prediction. The economic case, including carbonization energy and yield, is not analyzed, and the best bio-based filler dosage will depend on where that yield lands.

Bottom line

Bio-based filler dosage from sunflower husk carbonizate is workable, and the carbonization temperature is the variable that makes it work. Carbonizates produced in argon at 700 and 800 degrees Celsius reached tensile strength within 0.3 MPa of N772 carbon black at the same loading, lifted the torque difference to 27.1 and 26.7 dN m against 23.9 dN m, and raised crosslink density by 10 to 11 percent against the carbon black compound. The cost is processing viscosity, shorter scorch safety, and a 42 to 49 percent loss of elongation at break after aging. The low-temperature materials and the ash variant are not reinforcement routes, and 15 phr is the only loading in this set that competes with carbon black.

FAQ

What is bio-based filler dosage in rubber

It is the amount of a plant-derived filler, measured in parts per 100 parts of rubber, added to a compound to modify stiffness, strength, and cost. In this study sunflower husk carbonizates were dosed at 5.0, 10.0, and 15.0 phr and compared against N772 carbon black at the same loadings. Only the 15 phr level matched the carbon black compound on tensile strength.

How does carbonization temperature change the filler

It controls how completely the plant structure breaks down. Specific surface area climbed from 13 to 103 square meters per gram between 300 and 800 degrees Celsius, and pH rose from 7.3 to 10.2 as acidic groups were lost. Materials treated below 500 degrees Celsius retained enough unreacted biomass to release gas during vulcanization and leave voids.

Why does bio-based filler increase Mooney viscosity

Because thermally treated plant particles are rigid and porous. They restrict segmental mobility of the rubber macromolecules, reduce shear deformation, and make it harder for chains to slide past one another. Viscosity rose by up to 11.1 percent at 5 phr, 19.6 percent at 10 phr, and 29.8 percent at 15 phr in this compound.

Can sunflower husk carbonizate replace carbon black

Only at the top loading and only for strength. At 15 phr the 600, 700, and 800 degree carbonizates matched N772 carbon black within 0.3 MPa of tensile strength. They did not match it on elongation, where values fell by up to a factor of 1.3, or on aging, where elongation at break dropped by as much as 48.7 percent.

What is the difference between carbonizate and husk ash

Processing atmosphere. Carbonizates were made under argon at 300 to 800 degrees Celsius and keep a carbon skeleton. The ash was burned in an oxidizing atmosphere at 650 degrees Celsius, which destroys the carbon framework and leaves a mineral residue at pH 11.1. The ash reduced tensile strength by 21.7 to 43.2 percent against carbon black.

Why does the ash shorten scorch time so much

Because its surface is strongly alkaline, at pH 11.1. An alkaline surface accelerates the sulfur reaction, and scorch time dropped by up to 61.1 percent against the unfilled compound and 54.3 percent against the carbon black compound. That leaves little safety margin before a compound starts curing prematurely in the mill or the die.

Why does high surface area slow the cure

Because the surface adsorbs components of the vulcanizing system. Carbonizates made at higher temperatures have more surface area, so they tie up accelerator and sulfur and limit their availability. That is why time to reach optimum cure increased even though the early stage of the reaction was slightly faster.

How does filler loading affect crosslink density

It raises it. Crosslink density measured by equilibrium toluene swelling increased with loading for every carbonizate, and the highest values came from the 700 and 800 degree materials. Maximum torque rose by 11.1 and 10.0 percent against the carbon black compound, and the torque difference reached 27.1 and 26.7 dN m against 23.9 dN m.

What happens to these rubbers after thermal aging

Strength holds and elasticity drops. After 72 hours at 120 degrees Celsius, tensile strength changed by less than 8 percent for both carbon black and carbonizate filled compounds. Elongation at break fell by 42.1 percent for the 700 degree material and 48.7 percent for the 800 degree material, which points to metal-driven oxidation.

Which loading level makes sense for a first trial

Start at 10 phr. It captures most of the strength gain with a smaller processing penalty, since Mooney viscosity rises by up to 19.6 percent rather than 29.8 percent. The 5 phr level gains little strength, and 15 phr is the only level that matches carbon black but it also brings the largest viscosity and aging costs.

Does the filler change Shore A hardness

Only slightly. For carbonizates processed above 500 degrees Celsius at 15 phr, hardness moved upward but stayed within 3 Shore units, and the change grew with filler content. The shift is attributed to the higher crosslink density and the larger solid carbon fraction in those materials. A change that small is unlikely to move a specification on its own, but it does stack with any other hardness adjustment in the recipe.

What are the limits of this study

Only one rubber grade was tested, so the balance may shift in a matrix with different polarity. Carbon black was represented only by N772, a low-reinforcing grade, so no conclusion can be drawn against a high-reinforcing grade. Aging covered 72 hours at 120 degrees Celsius, which is a screening test rather than a lifetime prediction, and the carbonization energy and yield were not analyzed.